Evening Times: click here to return to our homepage
Complete rubbish
 
 
 
OVERALL, Scotland's recycling record is improving.<br>Mr Lochhead said: 'Recycling our household waste  be it bottles and cans or paper and plastic  is now very much a part of modern life for many of us in Scotland.<br>'We live in an era where simply throwing everything in the bin and seeing it end up as landfill is becoming increasingly unacceptable. This is, of course, a welcome change in culture. We must do everything we can to protect the earth's resources.<br>'However, I do feel we need to do more if we are to make further improvements and achieve the Scottish Government's aim of a 'Zero Waste Scotland'.<br>'Along with reusing plastic bags and using energy-saving light bulbs, recycling waste is one of the 10 'Greener' pledges that the Scottish Government launched earlier this year. I'd encourage everyone to sign up at www.infoscotland.com/ourfuture and make a difference.'
OVERALL, Scotland's recycling record is improving.
Mr Lochhead said: 'Recycling our household waste be it bottles and cans or paper and plastic is now very much a part of modern life for many of us in Scotland.
'We live in an era where simply throwing everything in the bin and seeing it end up as landfill is becoming increasingly unacceptable. This is, of course, a welcome change in culture. We must do everything we can to protect the earth's resources.
'However, I do feel we need to do more if we are to make further improvements and achieve the Scottish Government's aim of a 'Zero Waste Scotland'.
'Along with reusing plastic bags and using energy-saving light bulbs, recycling waste is one of the 10 'Greener' pledges that the Scottish Government launched earlier this year. I'd encourage everyone to sign up at www.infoscotland.com/ourfuture and make a difference.'
 
 

by Iain Lundy

GLASGOW is bottom of the pile in Scotland when it comes to recycling household waste.

The city's dire record in disposing of its waste in an environmentally-friendly manner has been highlighted in Scottish Government figures published today.

Reader Poll
Should Glasgow get more Government cash to boost recycling levels?
Yes
67.9%
No
29.9%
Don't know
2.2%

They show only 17.9% is recycled or composted - the lowest rate of any of Scotland's 32 local authorities.

And the figures also reveal Glasgow dumped 300,415 tonnes last year in landfill sites.

That was more than 100,000 tonnes higher than Edinburgh, which has the second highest landfill total, although Glasgow has a much bigger population.

Scotland's Environment Secretary Richard Lochhead was meeting Glasgow council leaders today for talks on how to improve the city's performance.

How your council fared:

GLASGOW produced 365,799 tonnes of waste, recycled 65,385 tonnes (17.9%) and landfilled 182,359 tonnes.

NORTH LANARKSHIRE produced 230,168 tonnes, recycled 68,105 tonnes (29.6%) and landfilled 162,064 tonnes.

SOUTH LANARKSHIRE produced 201,919 tonnes, recycled 76,458 tonnes (37.9%) and landfilled 125,461 tonnes.

EAST DUNBARTONSHIRE produced 74,909 tonnes, recycled 24,840 tonnes (33.2%) and landfilled 50,069 tonnes.

WEST DUNBARTONSHIRE produced 60,158 tonnes, recycled 19,823 tonnes (33.0%) and landfilled 40,335 tonnes.

RENFREWSHIRE produced 105,586 tonnes, recycled 30,381 tonnes (28.8%) and landfilled 75,205 tonnes.

EAST RENFREWSHIRE produced 56,074 tonnes, recycled 19,356 tonnes (34.5%) and landfilled 36,718 tonnes.

INVERCLYDE produced 52,244 tonnes, recycled 11,119 tonnes (21.3%) and landfilled 41,125 tonnes.

NORTH AYRSHIRE produced 90,184 tonnes, recycled 26,807 tonnes (29.7%) and landfilled 63,376 tonnes.

SOUTH AYRSHIRE produced 86,214 tonnes, recycled 35,636 tonnes (41.3%) and landfilled 50,578 tonnes.

EAST AYRSHIRE produced 73,798 tonnes, recycled 29,894 tonnes (40.5%) and landfilled 43,905 tonnes.

ARGYLL and BUTE produced 62,880 tonnes, recycled 21,635 tonnes (34.4%) and landfilled 41,245 tonnes.

He described the practice of waste ending up as landfill as "increasingly unacceptable".

Mr Lochhead said the aim of today's meeting was to try to give Scotland's largest city a greener outlook.

He added: "It has been suggested Glasgow's recycling performance is, in part, down to the number of people in the city living in tenements and tower blocks.

"This may be the case and it is one of the issues today's meeting will seek to address.

"As Scotland's biggest local authority, even a small increase would make a significant impact on the overall Scottish figure.

"A pot of £7.5million is available to fund community recycling projects and I would be delighted to see communities across Glasgow thinking about how to take advantage of what this offers."

The figures made available today reveal Glasgow produced 365,799 tonnes of municipal waste in 2007.

Of that, only 65,385 tonnes - 17.9% - was recycled. The remaining 300,414 tonnes were landfilled, including 182,359 tonnes of biodegradable waste.

The only other council that recycled less than 20% of its waste was Shetland, where 18.6% of its 12,146 tonnes was recycled.

Clackmannanshire and Moray led the way with 42.9%, followed by South Ayrshire on 41.3% and East Ayrshire on 40.5%.

Edinburgh produced 255,206 tonnes of waste and landfilled 185,847 tonnes. The capital's recycling rate was 27.3%.

Mr Lochhead said the figures showed a steady improvement, with 31.2% of waste in Scotland now being recycled, an increase of 4.1% on the previous year.

However, he added: "With ambitious targets now in place to achieve a Zero Waste Scotland, I want to see more being done, particularly in those areas where performance is below par.

"We need to make it as easy as possible for everyone to recycle and councils have a major role to play. "

The figures were released after the Evening Times conducted a survey last week of west Scotland councils to see who did what on the issue.

It revealed 31% of Glasgow households do not have any type of home recycling bin, but in East Renfrewshire nearly 99% of homes had access to recycling boxes and bins.

Patrick Harvie, the Green Party MSP, blamed the city's poor performance on a "lack of political will" by the council.

He said: "Glasgow has consistently been the worst city in Scotland for recycling and I think it is a historic lack of political will that is the problem.

"The city's Labour administration has always seemed more likely to find excuses, such as saying tenements are a problem, than to find solutions.

"Other cities in Europe cracked these problems years ago.

"It is something Glasgow should be doing a great deal better. Parts of the city are now just getting their first blue bags and even they do not carry certain types of waste, like cardboard and glass.

It is a poor show."

Mr Harvie said the council should be "more visible" in encouraging householders and the business community to recycle waste.

He added: "Everything is difficult until you figure it out. There are community projects in Glasgow that are a lot better on this issue than the council."

Responding to today's figures, a Glasgow City Council spokesman said: "It is true the city has some of the lowest household recycling rates in Scotland and this has been well documented.

"The major reason is the large number of tenements in Glasgow. Over the last two years we have been extending a project introducing recycling to tenements by means of blue sacks being issued to householders and large blue recycling bins being placed in communal back courts.

"This is expected to raise our recycling rate increase to 23% by the end of 2009.

"It should also be noted that while we are at the bottom of the league for recycling we still manage to recycle some 60,000 tonnes of material each year, which is a huge amount by anyone's standards.

"Glasgow has more than 90,000 householders using blue bins to recycle dry waste, 55,000 contributing to council-run composting programmes.

"In addition, there are many more using the city's network of 370 recycling points on a regular basis.

"We are fully committed to working with citizens and businesses to reduce Glasgow's reliance on landfill and make better use of recycling opportunities.

"The council is investing heavily in recycling and bringing forward plans to improve access to recycling in tenements - a particular challenge almost certainly greater in Glasgow than anywhere else in Scotland."

Publication date 27/05/08

Posted by: Sydney Meriwether, Glasgow on 11:30am Tue 27 May 08
A Glasgow City Council spokesman said:
... The major reason is the large number of tenements in Glasgow.

Doh! Tenements didn't just sprout overnight in Glasgow, did they? The fact is that Glasgow has been given millions of pounds to tackle its specific recycling shortcomings, but as usual it is money wasted by a decrepit city council administration, and the problems don't get better...


Evening Times September 13th 2006
DEAR GREEN PLACE?; Cash boost is set to save Glasgow from its poor rubbish dumping record and bring recycling to the tenements

BEGINS: A massive cash boost is about to haul Glasgow from the doldrums of Scotland's recycling league....

COUNCIL SPOKESMAN: "We have participated in the Scottish Executive's tenemental trial to assess different recycling collection systems.

"The trial has been received very positively by householders.

"It is hoped this trial will form the basis for securing further funding to extend the service to other tenemental properties across the city."

Now we get the same old story, just two years and many millions of mis-spent taxpayers pounds later!
Posted by: yerauldda, West End Exile on 12:39pm Tue 27 May 08
this at the same time north lanarkshire council has changed picking up your bins once a FORTNIGHT
rubbish bin one week, blue bin next week

oh rats!
Posted by: Anabelle, glasgow on 1:04pm Tue 27 May 08
It's all lip service from the council, there's no desire to improve their dire green credentials.

We've tried for well over a year to get recycling faacilities at our building to be told: "You're not in the right area for recycling", through to "we can't just give you recycling bins, it has to be looked at as part of the wider strategy into new-build properties". Residents WANTING to recycle, and thus increase the poor statistics for Glasgow are palmed off with excuses of bureaucracy - its disgraceful.
Posted by: Tarry breeks, Partick on 1:37pm Tue 27 May 08
There are plenty of people in my block who don't recycle, I don't think blame can be centred on the council given the apathy of many Glaswegians. The only solution is to charge taxpayers for landfill waste disposal with free kerbside recycling INCLUDING GLASS and a small 'free' landfill allowance.
Posted by: TSM, Glasgow on 1:58pm Tue 27 May 08
Glasgow is also one of the few councils that allows businesses to dump their rubbish on the street or near a bin, then collects it and calls it "household".

Watch for piles of cardboard all over the city that could, and should be recycled.

The daft thing is, many recycling companies will actually collect cardboard and plastic free of charge from commercial premises.
Posted by: Will, Glasgow on 2:14pm Tue 27 May 08
I asked for a blue and brown bin and was told if I wasnt on a current route then I woulnt get one.

WE RELLY WANT ANSWERS, SCOTLANDS SHAME.
Posted by: Judas, Glasgow on 2:53pm Tue 27 May 08
Two month old story?
http://www.eveningti
mes.co.uk/news/displ
ay.var.2093438.0.0.p
hp

--
Posted by: phylm01, Glasgow on 3:03pm Tue 27 May 08
I am an 89 year old and regularly separate all my rubbish for Glasgow City Council but yesterday being a Bank holiday only one truck arrived and all the bins i.e. black, blue etc were put into one truck and I asked how can they do that and they said it is okay to put it all together, surely not, why are we going to all the trouble to separate!!!!
Posted by: carol mallon, glasgow on 3:08pm Tue 27 May 08
So Glasgow is bottom in Scotland for recycling. We have a blue bin for recycling but it only gets emptied once a month even though ours can be filled after 2 weeks, so the rest has to go in the normal bin. We need collections at least fortnightly.
Posted by: Pete, Glasgow on 3:26pm Tue 27 May 08
I think it's important to recycle as much as possible so make make a special effort to fill the blue bin with as many empty beer cans as I can.

Everyone wins, and it's good to know you're doing your bit.
Posted by: mulross, Glasgow on 3:42pm Tue 27 May 08
Well, we have had the blue bins for a while now at our flats and it has made very little difference to the amount of rubbish being put in the ordinary bins. The reason?? A number of residents are too lazy to separate their rubbish. So, it's not entirely the fault of GCC - yes, they could do many things a great deal better, but the total apathy / selfishness of so many of our citizens is a tough nut to crack.
Posted by: Jaym, Glasgow on 3:57pm Tue 27 May 08
I do my bit. I don't buy the ET so I don't have to throw it away and as a result the land fill sites don't get filled up.
Posted by: Le Roi Des Voleurs, East Kilbride on 4:42pm Tue 27 May 08
I seem to remember the previous director of environmental services went on a trip to OZ to a recycling conference to see how to improve Glasgows performance...all paid for by the good council tax payers of Glasgow....good to see the trip was worthwhile
Posted by: renniemac, cumbernauld on 5:54pm Tue 27 May 08
typical of Glasgow City fathers too busy making their workers lives a misery, to get their act together. by the way the binmen boycotted overtime. they were not on strike over the Holidays. the council Leaders should start to do the job they are paid to do. why dont they ask other councils how they do it. as it looks like boothe, purcel and co, dont know what they are doing. too busy patting each other on the back over the commonwealth games bid. com'on do your job.
Posted by: expat john, Canada on 6:10pm Tue 27 May 08
Posted by: mulross, Glasgow on 3:42pm today "...So, it's not entirely the fault of GCC - yes, they could do many things a great deal better, but the total apathy / selfishness of so many of our citizens is a tough nut to crack"

Goos post Mulross. I'm afraid you only have to look at some of the posts in the ET to confirm this. I was born & raised in Glasgow & unfortunately I found most people seen the glass as half empty most of the time. The phrase 'the Council/Government should do it' was always paramount. Well, when it comes to recycling it's everyones responsibility. Over here when I tell my 2 year old to put something in the garbage, she asks which one it goes in (garbage or recycling), so at her early age she already knows there is a difference. The way I see it you have 3 choices in Glasgow. Do it yourself to help the enviroment & keep the GCC costs down. Let GCC do it but put up with increased costs & services so they can EMPLOY someone to do it for you....or knock down all the tenements as apparently it's all their fault!!! ;-) Can you recycle tenements?????
Posted by: jacksonja, home on 7:07pm Tue 27 May 08
i live in the riddrie area of glasgow,we have had recycling bins for a number of years now and it has worked well, that is up until yesterday monday 26th may when the refuse collectors decided to put all the domestic waste and the recycling waste all in the one truck,what a waste,get your act together cleansing department....whats the point?
Posted by: Me, Glasgow on 7:29pm Tue 27 May 08
Our bins are still sitting on the pavement waiting to be emptied, should have been garden waste yesterday and household today. no wonder nothing gets recycled if it doesn't get uplifted.
Posted by: P4J, Glasgow on 8:31pm Tue 27 May 08
I live in Glasgow, do not live up a tenement and have no blue, brown or purple bin. So how come the existence of tenements explains the city being rubbish at recycling? I was on holiday in France recently and had details of which of the 3 bins my rubbish had to go in, they were collected weekly, and it was easy. If the council had the will to make it happen they could make it happen.
Posted by: Lowflo, Glasgow on 9:10pm Tue 27 May 08


"recycling to tenements by means of blue sacks being issued to householders and large blue recycling bins being placed in communal back courts" Who is this eejit? I don't have any bins, since the council stole mine , nor do I have any sacks, blue black or otherwise, so for 25+ years I have recycled and/or re-used waste. But now there are these blue bits of plastic added to the green bits of plastic littered around by the council and lazy neighbours and still more rubbish left around by all and sundry. Put a bin somewhere and someone will add their rubbish to the patch of ground around it, and who is it who keeps adding glass to the plastic recycling bin, whoever it is they don't want to be identified because they do it in the dead of night, just as you nod off to sleep. Smash!smash!smash! and let's rattle the bin a bit more! I think I know where I'll recycle them when I catch them!
Posted by: BM, Glasgow on 9:28pm Tue 27 May 08
yerauldda wrote:
this at the same time north lanarkshire council has changed picking up your bins once a FORTNIGHT
rubbish bin one week, blue bin next week

oh rats!
That would be the same North Lanarkshire Council who made a good start with recycling but then decided that only paper (but excluding envelopes) was recyclable. They started well with bottles, tins, etc. then decided that recycling these items was not worthwhile.
However, at least they're not as bad as the English council who impose huge fines on householders who put rubbish into the wrong bin, but then mix and landfill it all!
Posted by: c-gull, the west coast on 10:24pm Tue 27 May 08
The more rubbish recycled means less food for me
Posted by: trench, possilpark on 12:37am Wed 28 May 08
i remember when i was young it was explained to me " you always know who the wealthy people are by their rubbish....they have more than everyone else," it could be they have more 'candlelight dinners and wine bottles'....that lets me out!
Posted by: wee malky on 7:04am Wed 28 May 08
who gives a toss anyway, don't recycle never will - by the time things go tits up on the planet, I'll be long gone anyway.
Posted by: buccleuch, Glasgow on 10:37am Wed 28 May 08
It just seems incredible that organising bins is beyond the capabilities of this council. And when bins are supplied they are often in the most inappropriate place like bang in front of the entrance of hillhead underground station. filthy, overspilling and in your face.
The sooner, the labour cooncilors are thrown out of glasgow the better
Posted by: buccleuch, Glasgow on 10:38am Wed 28 May 08
It just seems incredible that organising bins is beyond the capabilities of this council. And when bins are supplied they are often in the most inappropriate place like bang in front of the entrance of hillhead underground station. filthy, overspilling and in your face.
The sooner, the labour cooncilors are thrown out of glasgow the better
Posted by: buccleuch, Glasgow on 10:40am Wed 28 May 08
It just seems incredible that organising bins is beyond the capabilities of this council. And when bins are supplied they are often in the most inappropriate place like bang in front of the entrance of hillhead underground station. filthy, overspilling and in your face.
The sooner, the labour cooncilors are thrown out of glasgow the better
Posted by: Hobbes, Glasgow on 3:33pm Wed 28 May 08
As you can't recycle cartons, margarine tubs, yoghurt pots, cardboard packaging or glass in your Glasgow blue bin, it is little wonder that Glasgow is bottom of the league.
All I can put in my blue bin is my plastic milk bottle and the odd newspaper.
Posted by: Alex Mack, Glasgow on 3:49pm Wed 28 May 08
As i said on an earlier post if ow would read the lid of their Blue Bin it would tell you what you can and cannot recycle,the problem is Glasgow only wants its public to recycle items it can sell on and make money from it.
Add your comment
Please note: to publish your comment you must be registered on this site. If you are already registered, please enter your details below.
Email:
Password:
Travel Shop
Airport Parking
Travel Insurance
Car Hire
Copyright © 2009 Newsquest (Herald & Times) Limited. All Rights Reserved
Terms of Use