Evening Times: click here to return to our homepage
£1bn price tag if Glasgow Airport is sold off
 
 
 

by Brian Currie

GLASGOW Airport could have a price tag of more than £1billion if it is sold off.

BAA bosses were left furious today after the Competition Commission signalled the break up of its UK empire and recommended it lose control of either Glasgow or Edinburgh airport.

West's best as air hub rises to challenge

GLASGOW Airport could soon be at the centre of a multi-million pound sell-off just as it regains its crown as Scotland's busiest air terminal.

Almost one million passengers jetted in and out of the city hub last month despite rising fuel prices and the credit crunch hitting the holiday trade.

Reader Poll
BAA has been told it must sell either of its airports in Glasgow or Edinburgh.Would a sell-off of Glasgow Airport be bad news for the city?
Yes
29.0%
No
64.7%
Don't know
6.3%

In July Glasgow knocked its Edinburgh rival into second place for the first time this year when it snatched back its title.

It handled 939,204 passengers last month - almost 35,000 more than Edinburgh - but although international traffic was up 0.3% compared with July last year domestic traffic fell by 7.9%.

Holidaymakers using charter flights also dropped by 3%.

Overall passenger numbers at Glasgow last month fell by 3.2% on July 2007.

Gordon Dewar, managing director of Glasgow Airport, said: "With fuel prices still too high and consumer spending dented by the credit crunch airlines around the world are feeling the pinch and Scotland is not immune."

And he warned: "The next few months will be difficult.

"However, we are confident growth will return and we are still actively talking to new and existing airlines about how they can share in Scotland's success."

A BAA Glasgow spokesman said today: "We remain focused on delivering for our passengers, and continuing the investment that has transformed our airports."

With business passenger numbers growing at Edinburgh while Glasgow relies more on charter flights, it's thought the west of Scotland airport is the more likely to be sold.

Bosses said it was "business as usual" at the airports today but made plain their intention to fight the ruling during the consultation period.

The Competition Commission also said Spanish-owned BAA should give up two of its three of its London airports - Heathrow, Gatwick and Stansted.

It said there were competition problems at each of BAA's seven UK airports "with adverse consequences for passengers and airlines".

The sell-off was welcomed by Cathcart MSP Charlie Gordon who, when he was leader of Glasgow City Council, was a strong critic of BAA and floated the idea of buying the airport.

Today he said: "It doesn't matter whether it's Glasgow or Edinburgh that's sold because no matter which one goes it means that whoever owns Glasgow Airport - and it could still be BAA - they will no longer have divided loyalties.

"They will have to do their best to attract as much traffic as possible for Glasgow whereas there has always been the suspicion, rightly or wrongly, that for whatever confidential commercial reasons sometimes BAA diverted new routes from Glasgow if that suited their purpose even though the carrier was interested in coming to the city.

"The break-up makes things more transparent and Glasgow will be operating on a level playing field."

Council leader Steven Purcell said the airport was a "fantastic asset" and predicted there would be no shortage of potential buyers.

They could include the Peel Group, which owns Clydeport. It already operates Liverpool John Lennon Airport, Durham Tees Valley Airport, Robin Hood Airport Doncaster Sheffield and the small City Airport in Manchester.

There has also been speculation that Australian investment group Macquarie and Manchester Airport Group could be interested.

Manchester, which is used by many Scots to fly across the Atlantic, also owns East Midlands, Bournemouth and Humberside airports.

Eight local authorities in the Manchester area have a stake in running the international airport and made an operating profit of around £26million last year.

Glasgow City Council has no plans to bid.

Lack of competition was the main reason for the recommendations by the commission.

Chairman Christopher Clarke said: "We have provisionally found that there are significant competition problems arising from BAA's common ownership of seven UK airports.

"This is evident from a large number of factors including its lack of responsiveness to the needs of its airline customers and a lack of initiative in planning capacity.

"This has resulted in investment that is not tailored to the requirements of airport users and lower levels and quality of service for both airlines and passengers."

In Scotland, where BAA also owns Aberdeen Airport, he said "separate owners of Edinburgh and Glasgow would improve their offerings".

Mr Clarke added: "BAA has argued to us that there is no scope for competition to develop so long as there are capacity constraints.

"We take the opposite view. Unless the market is opened up to competition, there is a serious risk that the current capacity constraints will persist.

"In Scotland, BAA has until recently been noticeably slow to develop new routes at Glasgow and Edinburgh."

A Scottish government spokesman said "it welcomed the opportunity afforded by competition".

The report had still to be studied in detail but he added: "Competition could bring benefits to Scotland."

Labour transport spokesman Des McNulty said: "If Glasgow Airport is to be sold off, any new owner must show a strong commitment to the city. We need to see continued investment to safeguard jobs and protect the interests of passengers."

Gordon Dewar of BAA Scotland said the firm's opinion was shared by many leading Scots business organisations.

He said: "We remain of the view that Glasgow and Edinburgh airports serve separate markets and that competition between the two is highly unlikely, regardless of ownership.

"We are disappointed the Competition Commission has chosen to take a different view, following what appears to be a flawed analysis of our airports. The consultation that will now follow provides us and others with the opportunity to respond in detail as the investigation enters its next stage.

"However, we strongly believe BAA's stewardship of Aberdeen, Edinburgh and Glasgow airports has served Scotland well.

"We are delivering record investment in our airports, reducing our landing charges year on year, maintaining high levels of customer service for our passengers and ensuring Scotland is better connected to the world than ever before."

Richard Cairns, chief executive of the Glasgow Chamber of Commerce, said: "The relationship Glasgow has with BAA has been very positive. They built a special low-cost terminal for easyJet, for example. We would hope any other operator is as strongly committed to Glasgow."

Sale 'threat' to city jobs

HUNDREDS of jobs could be under threat if Glasgow Airport is sold off.

That was the warning today from leaders of Britain's biggest trade union, Unite, which has repeatedly opposed any attempt to break-up BAA's monopoly.

Brian Boyd, national officer for civil air transport, said: "What seems to be missing from all this talk is that when a monopoly is broken up, it usually affects livelihoods."

He fears a new operator will cut jobs and tear-up existing "hard fought for" terms and conditions.

He added: "We are against any sell-off. We don't think it is necessary, but if it is inevitable, then we would want safeguards put in place for existing staff."

There are more than 450 workers directly employed at Glasgow Airport and an additional 200 at a neighbouring BAA business support centre.

Union leader Donald Munro, who represents airport workers across Scotland, said: "Like many, I have felt that Glasgow Airport was the one most likely to be sold - but BAA have told me not to take it as read.

"However, anyone who comes in and thinks they can run the airport on the cheap by attacking the pay and conditions of my members can think again."

Publication date 20/08/08

Posted by: Sydney Meriwether, Glasgow on 11:10am Wed 20 Aug 08
With rapidly decreasing tourists, retail sales, and hotel occupancy rates in Glasgow, you'll be lucky if the crumbling airport could be flogged for the prince of a pint at one of its bars!

--
Sydney Meriwether
"The voice of Glasgow's silenced majority."
Posted by: The Missing City, Glasgow on 11:18am Wed 20 Aug 08
Glasgow City Council has no plans to bid


They'll be greetin at the fact its worth a billion buckeroos and will be raging that their predecessors sold it back in the 70's.

Thing is, it appeared that politicians had very little braqins when it came to investing for the future - they sniffed a few measley sheckles and grabbed the paltry sum they got back in the day.

Good luck to the airport, whoever takes over will ensure that it continues to be a successful operation and good for the people of the West of Scotland.

Posted by: The Missing City, Glasgow on 11:20am Wed 20 Aug 08
The Missing City wrote:
Glasgow City Council has no plans to bid
They'll be greetin at the fact its worth a billion buckeroos and will be raging that their predecessors sold it back in the 70's. Thing is, it appeared that politicians had very little braqins when it came to investing for the future - they sniffed a few measley sheckles and grabbed the paltry sum they got back in the day. Good luck to the airport, whoever takes over will ensure that it continues to be a successful operation and good for the people of the West of Scotland.
PS The council have been selling the silver ever since ;-)

Who cares about people or history, as long as there's money to be made, that's all that matters to GCC.
Posted by: Sydney Meriwether, Glasgow on 11:21am Wed 20 Aug 08
The Missing City wrote:
Glasgow City Council has no plans to bid


They'll be greetin at the fact its worth a billion buckeroos and will be raging that their predecessors sold it back in the 70's.

Thing is, it appeared that politicians had very little braqins when it came to investing for the future - they sniffed a few measley sheckles and grabbed the paltry sum they got back in the day.

Good luck to the airport, whoever takes over will ensure that it continues to be a successful operation and good for the people of the West of Scotland.

Exactly, if we had a decent (not decrepit) council like Manchester, we could be reaping the rewards of a flourishing airport.

--
Sydney Meriwether
"The voice of Glasgow's silenced majority."
Posted by: jamie_th, Glasgow on 11:31am Wed 20 Aug 08
Wow Snydey,

Is that praise for a Labour council I hear there?
Posted by: jim, Glasgow on 11:50am Wed 20 Aug 08
Reyail sales are dropping everywhere .rather still shop in Glasgow than Edinburgh that has No shops at all,It will be good for the area no matter what happens.
Posted by: Sydney Meriwether, Glasgow on 11:56am Wed 20 Aug 08
jim wrote:
Reyail sales are dropping everywhere .rather still shop in Glasgow than Edinburgh that has No shops at all,It will be good for the area no matter what happens.
Retail sales are NOT "dropping everywhere", there are small falls in most places and increases in some, but in Glasgow sales at the shops are in freefall, evidenced by the sales at benchmark store John Lewis:
The chain's three Scottish stores experienced mixed fortunes. While Aberdeen racked up an 8.1 per cent rise in overall sales, the outlets in Edinburgh and Glasgow fell by 1.9 and 7.7 per cent, respectively.


--
Sydney Meriwether
"The voice of Glasgow's silenced majority."
Posted by: doug, glasgow on 11:58am Wed 20 Aug 08
How can any sell off be good?
1) name a company that will spend the money to grow the airport
2)most pepole think change of owners the q's will go away wrong they will still be there

glasgow has plenty of Competition from prestwick and edinburgh because it has a different focus being holiday flights and flights around the world ie america and pakistan and the middle east.

if you look at the things that go on in and around glasgow ie football games, golf and the future 2014 games then the airport should stay with a company that will grow it to match the demand, which yes has been down but look at the high street shops spending is down but shops still expand.

I think ferrovial should put up a fight as they have only owned the baa for 2 years they have not been given a proper chance to sort years of money grabin ceo's and share holders.

Even if gcc were to pay the £1 back that they sold it for they still would not run it aswell a the public think.
Posted by: jim, Glasgow on 12:03pm Wed 20 Aug 08
Sydney Meriwether wrote:
jim wrote: Reyail sales are dropping everywhere .rather still shop in Glasgow than Edinburgh that has No shops at all,It will be good for the area no matter what happens.
Retail sales are NOT "dropping everywhere", there are small falls in most places and increases in some, but in Glasgow sales at the shops are in freefall, evidenced by the sales at benchmark store John Lewis:
The chain's three Scottish stores experienced mixed fortunes. While Aberdeen racked up an 8.1 per cent rise in overall sales, the outlets in Edinburgh and Glasgow fell by 1.9 and 7.7 per cent, respectively.
-- Sydney Meriwether "The voice of Glasgow's silenced majority."
You have to stop reading the Scottish Sun!Retails have fllen dramatically in every town and large city.its a FACT.End.
Posted by: fredo, paisley on 12:03pm Wed 20 Aug 08
Sydney Meriwether wrote:
The Missing City wrote:
Glasgow City Council has no plans to bid
They'll be greetin at the fact its worth a billion buckeroos and will be raging that their predecessors sold it back in the 70's. Thing is, it appeared that politicians had very little braqins when it came to investing for the future - they sniffed a few measley sheckles and grabbed the paltry sum they got back in the day. Good luck to the airport, whoever takes over will ensure that it continues to be a successful operation and good for the people of the West of Scotland.
Exactly, if we had a decent (not decrepit) council like Manchester, we could be reaping the rewards of a flourishing airport. -- Sydney Meriwether "The voice of Glasgow's silenced majority."
the airport has nothing to do with glasgow it has a pa1 postcode sort yourselfs out is glasgow prestwich purcells as well
Posted by: Sydney Meriwether, Glasgow on 12:05pm Wed 20 Aug 08
fredo wrote:
Sydney Meriwether wrote:
The Missing City wrote:
Glasgow City Council has no plans to bid
They'll be greetin at the fact its worth a billion buckeroos and will be raging that their predecessors sold it back in the 70's. Thing is, it appeared that politicians had very little braqins when it came to investing for the future - they sniffed a few measley sheckles and grabbed the paltry sum they got back in the day. Good luck to the airport, whoever takes over will ensure that it continues to be a successful operation and good for the people of the West of Scotland.
Exactly, if we had a decent (not decrepit) council like Manchester, we could be reaping the rewards of a flourishing airport. -- Sydney Meriwether "The voice of Glasgow's silenced majority."
the airport has nothing to do with glasgow it has a pa1 postcode sort yourselfs out is glasgow prestwich purcells as well
Spray that again would you fredo!

--
Sydney Meriwether
"The voice of Glasgow's silenced majority."
Posted by: RapidAssistant, Glasgow on 12:12pm Wed 20 Aug 08
Sydney Meriwether wrote:
With rapidly decreasing tourists, retail sales, and hotel occupancy rates in Glasgow, you'll be lucky if the crumbling airport could be flogged for the prince of a pint at one of its bars! -- Sydney Meriwether "The voice of Glasgow's silenced majority."
If so then at least a pint in J.R Tennent's Bar will be cheaper when you want to fly away from the apocalyptic shanty town that you keep predicting Glasgow is going to become. YAWN!!
Posted by: Mark Pittman, Glasgow on 12:49pm Wed 20 Aug 08
There is nothing more constant in business and life than change. In my opinion the break up of BAA will prove to be worthwhile long term. It's time the tree was shaken.
Posted by: Ian, Glasgow on 1:24pm Wed 20 Aug 08
Ha ha I've not been on the ET website for a while but its re-assuring to see that 'Sydney Meriwether' and 'The Missing City' are still here with more of the same anti-Labour/Purcell/
GCC rants. Then again, I'd reckon they are both one and the same person anyway.

Back to the story in question - Lets hope Glasgow Airport gets sold as any new owner will have the airports best interests at heart and not be balancing the books / making the most of the current monopoly of Scotland's 2 major cities.
Posted by: Rob O, UK on 1:28pm Wed 20 Aug 08
Cathcart MSP Charlie Gordon is making completely unfounded and serious accusations in this article. I am certainly not aware of any airlines being "diverted form GLA to EDI. The aviation industry is driven by suppy and demand. If there was enough demand from either GLA or EDI areas for airlines to fly a certain route you can bet they would not be slow on the uptake. All the talk about BAA restricting Scotland's connections with the world is just rubbish. You can also bet that any new owner would be hard pushed to match the levels of investment Glasgow has seen in recent yeras. The Government need to take a large proportion of the blame for the current state of civil aviation in the UK. But why tale responsibility when you can blame someone else!
Posted by: The Missing City, Glasgow on 1:44pm Wed 20 Aug 08
Ian wrote:
Ha ha I've not been on the ET website for a while but its re-assuring to see that 'Sydney Meriwether' and 'The Missing City' are still here with more of the same anti-Labour/Purcell/ GCC rants. Then again, I'd reckon they are both one and the same person anyway. Back to the story in question - Lets hope Glasgow Airport gets sold as any new owner will have the airports best interests at heart and not be balancing the books / making the most of the current monopoly of Scotland's 2 major cities.
You wish boy, you wish

Besides, most people can't handle the truth!

That's why they read The Nation's Favourite

The Daily Record.
Posted by: exiled scot, hampshire on 1:53pm Wed 20 Aug 08
the small City Airport in Manchester

what small city airport in Manchester? Didn't know there was one.

perhaps the sell off of Glasgow Airport will mean cheaper landing fees, the move of Ryanair from Prestwick to Glasgow and the eventual closure of that joke of an airport on the Ayrshire coast.
Posted by: George Brown, erskine on 2:35pm Wed 20 Aug 08
sell it to the arabs on condition that they flatten it bury it in sand and find some oil
and give the surrounding countryside some peace and quiet at night for a change
Posted by: Foxy, Brigadoon on 2:48pm Wed 20 Aug 08
I don't know where the £1bn figure is coming from, last I read - in the business broadsheets - it was quoted at a sensible £350M.
Posted by: doug, glasgow on 4:18pm Wed 20 Aug 08
god and i thought this was a story about gla airport not which town or city it is in on who might buy it if it were up for sale
Posted by: 2for1, Glasgow on 5:46pm Wed 20 Aug 08
As someone who works for an airline flying out of Glasgow, the best thing in my oppinion is for it to be sold! As has been mentioned by several people on here... Edinburgh has been preffered to Glasgow by BAA the easyjet "terminal" (translated = joke!) is a token gesture as Logan Air and Aer Lingus also use it... hardly a low cost terminal(!), also, BAA are ripping off the retail units by taking their 40% - this was also covered in a Dispatches programme (mind you, Dispatches = 1 hour of p*ss poor editing to show the predjudiced oppinion of the editor!) and the landing fees at Glasgow ARE the reason Ryanair won't come to Glasgow - I should know... I used to work for them and asked!!! Love or hate Ryan, they go where the money talks and given that Ryan and BAA are at war in Stansted, there's no way BAA 'Scotland' would be allowed by big brother down south to negotiate with them!

Independance of Glasgow airport is the best thing that can happen... if not aleady dried up, the Scottish Route Development Fund should be raided by Glasgow, as it has been a constant cash-cow for Edinburgh to milk dry over the years, purely to satisfy the egos of MSP's with a mentality of "Capital City must have as many routes as possible" even though the commercial (not political!) powerhouse of Scotland is West-Central Scotland... funnily enough were Glasgow is! So, get it sold, get it independant, safeguard our jobs, get the god-damned rail link built NOW and stop glossing over the situation with "Glasgows a charter flight airport" - BS - it's an international gateway to Scotland... lets take what BAA has (thankfully) invested in the airport and make it work for Glasgow AND Scotland!

Grrrrr....!
Posted by: 2for1, Glasgow on 5:53pm Wed 20 Aug 08
One other thing...

Quite a coincidence the MD of the airport has recently anounced he is to take over the role of MD at Edinburgh... just as Glasgow's passenger numbers have been in freefall! so what motivation for making Glasgow the top airport has there been over the past few months whilst he has been scratching his a*se waiting for his transfer? He's hardly going to build up what will now be his competing airport, is he!? Further reasoning why it should be independant and competing with both Edinburgh and Prestwick... the "Pure dead brilliant" cargo terminal! (Don't get me started on that dump!!!)

Double 'Grrrrrrr'!
Posted by: monty, scotland on 6:35pm Wed 20 Aug 08
£1Billion, £350 million? I've no idea how they determine the value of an airport. The value of the land at Glasgow alone must be considerable, never mind the airport business. Hopefully whoever buys Glasgow will close it down and build houses giving those of us on the flight path a bit of peace.
Posted by: 2for1, Glasgow on 6:47pm Wed 20 Aug 08
monty wrote:
£1Billion, £350 million? I've no idea how they determine the value of an airport. The value of the land at Glasgow alone must be considerable, never mind the airport business. Hopefully whoever buys Glasgow will close it down and build houses giving those of us on the flight path a bit of peace.
I have as much sympathy for people like you as the people who buy houses on known flood planes... IF YOU DONT WANT AIRCRAFT NOISE WHY BUY A HOUSE UNDER A FLIGHT PATH?!?!?!?!?!?!?!
People like you are the types who buy at Glasgow Harbour and complain about the noise from the shipyards across the water!
So, going on your idea, will the hundreds of people who work at the airport, and several hundred others indirectly employed by the airport all be taken on as laborours, or should we all just be made redundant and loose our homes 'cause you cant handle the noise of a a few jet engines!?!?!?!?

Get a life!
Posted by: lavalamp, coatbridge on 8:18pm Wed 20 Aug 08
Glasgow airport is big enough
Posted by: George Square, Glasgow on 9:02pm Wed 20 Aug 08
Sydney Meriwether wrote:
With rapidly decreasing tourists, retail sales, and hotel occupancy rates in Glasgow, you'll be lucky if the crumbling airport could be flogged for the prince of a pint at one of its bars! -- Sydney Meriwether "The voice of Glasgow's silenced majority."
Flaming Sydney!

Another dose of Syd's negative and usually wrong, inshight!

Now there's a surprise!
Posted by: fredo, paisley on 9:24pm Wed 20 Aug 08
George Square wrote:
Sydney Meriwether wrote: With rapidly decreasing tourists, retail sales, and hotel occupancy rates in Glasgow, you'll be lucky if the crumbling airport could be flogged for the prince of a pint at one of its bars! -- Sydney Meriwether "The voice of Glasgow's silenced majority."
Flaming Sydney! Another dose of Syd's negative and usually wrong, inshight! Now there's a surprise!
sydney is a bampot he,ll be in his scratcher had a long day today.Am glad am not the only one sick of his pish
Posted by: fredo, paisley on 9:29pm Wed 20 Aug 08
editor where are all the comments from today?
Posted by: Foxhound, W.o.Scotland on 11:29pm Wed 20 Aug 08
George Brown wrote:
sell it to the arabs on condition that they flatten it bury it in sand and find some oil and give the surrounding countryside some peace and quiet at night for a change
AAH a nimby! I am hoping for a second runway and if one doesnt want to live near an Airport
that is ones choice afaik .
Bring on the Jumbos !
Posted by: Foxhound, W.o.Scotland on 8:42am Thu 21 Aug 08
It has been obvious for a number of years that BAA has been persuading flights to choose Edinburgh over Glasgow and investing much more in Edinburgh Airport .
The BAA had made their minds up along time ago that they were keeping and going to build up Edinburgh at the expense of our airport .
Well bring in the new owners and at least we will have a level playing field instead of the situation we have at the moment !

Posted by: Andy Logan, Mount Florida on 10:31am Thu 21 Aug 08
The sooner Abbotsinch is sold the better, shouldnt take long to strip the assets thats for sure!
Posted by: Andy Logan, Mount Florida on 10:33am Thu 21 Aug 08
exiled scot wrote:
the small City Airport in Manchester what small city airport in Manchester? Didn't know there was one. perhaps the sell off of Glasgow Airport will mean cheaper landing fees, the move of Ryanair from Prestwick to Glasgow and the eventual closure of that joke of an airport on the Ayrshire coast.
I'm sure the folk employed at Prestwick will be happy knowing that you want them to lose their jobs so the Glasgow plane-spotting fraternity can write down more numbers.
Posted by: Andy Logan, Mount Florida on 10:35am Thu 21 Aug 08
Foxy wrote:
I don't know where the £1bn figure is coming from, last I read - in the business broadsheets - it was quoted at a sensible £350M.
Even £350m seems a bit optimistic for an airport whose passenger numbers are in freefall decline.
Posted by: Andy Logan, Mount Florida on 10:37am Thu 21 Aug 08
Foxhound wrote:
It has been obvious for a number of years that BAA has been persuading flights to choose Edinburgh over Glasgow and investing much more in Edinburgh Airport . The BAA had made their minds up along time ago that they were keeping and going to build up Edinburgh at the expense of our airport . Well bring in the new owners and at least we will have a level playing field instead of the situation we have at the moment !
What utter tosh, Emirates at Glasgow shoots that theory down, airlines choose where they fly, not plane-spotters.
Add your comment
Please note: to publish your comment you must be registered on this site. If you are already registered, please enter your details below.
Email:
Password:
Travel Shop
Airport Parking
Travel Insurance
Car Hire
Copyright © 2009 Newsquest (Herald & Times) Limited. All Rights Reserved
Terms of Use