Truth 'could have saved students'

TWO students killed when a car mounted the pave-ment and smashed into them would still be alive if the driver had told the truth, a fatal acci-dent inquiry heard.

Loading Comments

Consultant cardio-logist Dr Neil Grubb prepared a report based on medical information given about William Payne, 53, - that he had blacked out on four occasions - and it was "reasonable" he wasn't told to stop driving.

But after being told at the inquiry that Mr Payne told another doctor during a medical test for his HGV licence that he had not suffered blackouts Dr Grubb said that was "wrong".

Mr Payne, of Bishop-briggs, was driving his 4x4 on December 17, 2010, in North Hanover Street, Glasgow, when he collided with Mhairi Convy, 18, and Laura Stewart, 20. He also injured Mark Hopwood, 39, who survived.

Yesterday at Glasgow Sheriff Court, under cross-examination by Dorothy Bain QC, rep-resenting the families, Dr Grubb said that he would have ordered a tilt table test, which diagnoses fainting, as early as April 2008.

The inquiry heard that when Mr Payne had the test after the incident his heart paused for 10 seconds.

Dr Grubb said that it was "entirely possible" that if the test was carried out in April 2008 that it would have had the same result.

Miss Bain asked the witness: "If it had the same result you would have told him to stop driving?" Dr Grubb replied: "Yes."

She said: "What happ- ened to Miss Stewart and Miss Convy could have been avoided."

The consultant said: "Yes, if he had stopped driving, yes."

The doctor was told Mr Payne had suffered more blackouts than he was aware of before compiling his report.

Miss Bain told him that under the question to renew his HGV licence in July 2010 "Is there a history of blackouts or impaired consciousness in the last five years" that Mr Payne said no.

She asked: "That's wrong isn't it?" Dr Grubb said: "That's definitely wrong."

The QC asked: "If he told the truth in July 2010 would he be driving?" Dr Grubb said: "He certainly wouldn't be driving an HGV and I believe he probably wouldn't be driving his own car."

Miss Bain said: "If he told the truth the girls wouldn't have been killed?" The consultant said: "That's correct."

The inquiry, before sheriff Andrew Normand, continues.


Commenting & Moderation

We moderate all comments on Evening Times on either a pre-moderated or post-moderated basis. If you're a relatively new user then your comments will be reviewed before publication and if we know you well and trust you then your comments will be subject to moderation only if other users or the moderators believe you've broken the rules

Moderation is undertaken full-time 9am-6pm on weekdays, and on a part-time basis outwith those hours. Please be patient if your posts are not approved instantly.


Have you got a story?

Contact the news desk on 0141 302 6520 or email
Michelle McManus

Michelle McManus

Sussed in the City

I don’t think I’ve uttered the words “no, he’s not a stripper we’ve hired so put him down.




Janice Bell

Janice Bell

You couldn’t make up half the stuff that happens to PA Janice Bell- some of the jams she gets herself into are worth a story or two.

Games news:

Putting the world to rights

Gail's Gab

My thoughts after Police Scotland are ordered to apologise over IRA interrogation techniques slur.

Cat’s Eyes on Glasgow

Cat’s Eyes on Glasgow

Cat Cubie’s job is to find and share with you the fabulous things the city has to offer, from gigs to gastro.