Evening Times: click here to return to our homepage
HOLYROOD WEEK: It's all thud and blunder in Scots referendum row
 
Wendy Alexander's U-turn in demanding a referendum stunned many, if not most, of her Holyrood colleagues
Wendy Alexander's U-turn in demanding a referendum stunned many, if not most, of her Holyrood colleagues
 

by Brian Currie

THE question on Labour supporters' minds today should be: when does disarray become disintegration?

Gordon Brown is in a mess at Downing Street and Wendy Alexander is blundering all over the place in Scotland.

The fiasco over the "bring it on" referendum comment by Ms Alexander reveals a lack of any cohesive thinking at the top of the party. Mr Brown and Ms Alexander have squirmed their way through the week since her moment of bravado.

Maybe there was lots of distortion on the line when they spoke, since each of them appears to have a different interpretation of whether he was endorsing her position.

Despite her claims to the contrary, Ms Alexander's U-turn in demanding an independence referendum stunned many, if not most, of her Holyrood colleagues.

And the Prime Minister's failure to back her when questioned by Tory leader David Cameron has undermined her already diminished credibility.

Neither did Mr Brown do himself any favours by being ignorant of the SNP's plans for a referendum in 2010, despite it being clearly set out in its manifesto and mentioned frequently in news reports.

No wonder Ms Alexander and her advisers hid from the press for hours on Wednesday afternoon.


Almost to the exclusion of everything else this week, the referendum question has dominated Holyrood.

And, since she had backed herself into a corner, the Labour leaderette, had no option but to lead on it at First Minister's Questions.

It was made worse for her when she found herself being attacked by the Tories and LibDems, who criticised her rather than attacking the Government.

LibDems' leader Nicol Stephen put it best when he asked if Mr Salmond could believe his luck with his new best friends - the Tories - backing his policies for the last year and a Labour Party that had turned into a "farcical floor-show".

The referendum question is a gift for the Nats, who can simply say they are sticking to the schedule outlined in their manifesto while they prove themselves in government.

There was not the expected blood on the walls of the chamber because Mr Salmond was restrained.

Maybe he wants to keep Ms Alexander as opposition leader for as long as possible in case Labour finds someone less bad.

However, he could not resist the obvious reply when she said, in reference to the referendum: "I'm not the problem."

She could not have been surprised to be told she "wasn't the answer" either.

Week after week this Labour Party's leadership simply hands ammunition to the SNP. Ms Alexander is still Scottish leader - but for how long?


IT is highly unusual for the First Minister to miss the weekly Cabinet meeting.

It is where policy decisions are confirmed and responses to topical developments are discussed.

But Mr Salmond was missing from this week's he was at home in Strichen celebrating his 27th wedding anniversary.

The First Minister may not be frightened of Wendy Alexander or Tory boss Annabel Goldie, but obviously knows better than to antagonise wife Moira.

Publication date 09/05/08

Posted by: Zanardi, Glasgow on 3:48pm Fri 9 May 08
Week after week this Labour Party's leadership simply hands ammunition to the SNP. Ms Alexander is still Scottish leader - but for how long?


It's easy to suggest, but who exactly do Labour have who would offer improvement in any way, shape or form?

Andy Kerr? Duncan McNeill? Jackie Baillie? Cathy Jamieson? Margaret Jamieson? Pauline McNeil? Intellectual giants one and all, though I wouldn't bet tuppence that any of them would win an argument with a potato.

There is no-one at all within Scottish Labour capable of putting forward a credible case, either for Government or the Union. The zeitgeist has completely passed the bunch of public-sector soaked, myopic, inarticulate and thoroughly disreputable underachievers.

Labour: The Betamax of Scottish politics.
Posted by: James, Glasgow on 4:10pm Fri 9 May 08
Can't even do a U-turn efficiently. Scottish Labour should disband along with their UK counterparts and try to start again after they are massacred at the next election. Roll on 2010 and independence from the then Tory Westminster.
Posted by: Victor Smith on 9:37am Sat 10 May 08
Why don't the Scottish branch of the Labour Party see if Tony Blair would be their New Labour new leader, something I feel sure he could cope with as a simple 'Saturday morning job, and considering the state of the Party and his 'alleged' devotion to New Labour, plus the 'brass' he now has simply rolling into his bank account, he may - if pressed, mind you very hard pressed -it may come as a 'freebie' -or as near as dammit, but I may be wrong on this last point!
Add your comment
Please note: to publish your comment you must be registered on this site. If you are already registered, please enter your details below.
Email:
Password:
Travel Shop
Airport Parking
Travel Insurance
Copyright © 2008 Newsquest (Herald & Times) Limited. All Rights Reserved
Terms of Use