Evening Times: click here to return to our homepage
HOLYROOD WEEK: ID debate farce as MSPs are posted missing
 
Fergus Ewing
Fergus Ewing
 
 

by Brian Currie

IF you believe some MSPs, there aren't enough hours in the day for them to cope with their workload. And, of course, it's vital they break away from their constituency duties so the nation benefits from their collective wisdom as they debate the pressing issues of the moment.

The controversial plan to introduce identity cards is certainly important and it was debated again this week - the question is why?

Just because the decision will be made at Westminster and Holyrood has no influence on the outcome doesn't mean to say the Scottish Parliament should not make its views known.

But this is the third time the subject has been debated and the second time they have dedicated time to it in less than a year.

And surprise, surprise, ID cards are still unpopular.

The debate was a farce with fewer than 30 MSPs in the chamber when it started, though that in itself is not unusual.

However, that meant the 100 or so others obviously didn't think it was that important.

Presumably they were catching up with their other chores, though the number of them hanging around the Garden Lobby suggests otherwise - unless it was their turn to go for the coffee.

Fergus Ewing, who enjoys the Orwellian title of Minister for Community Safety, did make one good point when he questioned whether the UK Government would be able to keep the information secure.

Given the amount of data it has lost already this year, predicting the answer should not be difficult.

When people voted for a Scottish Parliament, did they know they were also voting for a pampered lifestyle for its employees?

In the last three years, the taxpayer has forked out £146,000 on diets, fitness classes and sports activities for staff.

Of that, £37,000 went on massages for the poor, overworked wee things.

According to a Holyrood spokesman, the perks help keep the staff "well-motivated and productive".

But isn't that what they get paid for?

If they aren't well-motivated and productive what are they doing to earn their wages?

It seems politicians aren't the only ones who recognise a gravy train when they see one.

The figures emerged because of a Freedom of Information request and Parliamentary Business Minister Bruce Crawford wants to extend the scope of the Act.

Mr Crawford, a highly-effective operator, is seeking views on extending it to cover registered social landlords, local authority trusts and contractors providing services for a public authority.

It will be interesting to see how Glasgow Housing Association and Glasgow City Council, which has numerous of these offshoots, respond.

The First Minister has a sore throat and had to cancel his engagements for a couple of days so he missed the Scotland against Argentina friendly on Wednesday.

It meant the legendary Hand of God' was not shaken but, according to Mr Salmond's supporters, there's still time for Maradona to achieve that ambition.

Publication date 21/11/08

Posted by: Senga Haw, Milngavie on 9:32pm Fri 21 Nov 08
The biased 'journalist' writing this is a well known Labour supporting muppett. So everything he writes has to be viewed in that context, the bias is obvious to all...
Posted by: murren59, Isle of Arran, Scotland. on 10:16pm Fri 21 Nov 08
I'm a SNP Life Member but I think that this article is well written, quite funny...and to the point.
All missing MSP's should be ashamed of themselves - especially our SNP ones. We need to be more dedicated and different from the London controlled unionist dross.
I don't know whether or not Mr.Currie is in fact a "well known labour muppet" but let's not get too paranoid here, Senga Haw.
Posted by: HGlasgwegian, Glasgow on 3:52pm Tue 25 Nov 08
It was an SNP motion on ID cards that MSPs were debating so no wonder there weren't many unionist MPSs present. They might have to explain why they are supporting them.
Posted by: HGlasgwegian, Glasgow on 3:56pm Tue 25 Nov 08
Incidentally the labour buffoon George Foulkes came out with something which could potentially be quite sinister during the debate. He said 'Another benefit has not been mentioned—ID cards prevent electoral fraud, because they allow voter identification at the point of voting.'

As far as I am aware the control freaks at Westminster are not proposing that people should have to carry an ID card to vote but perhaps that is next.
Posted by: Bear, Glasgow on 6:23pm Tue 25 Nov 08
a wudnt trust govermant wi personal info. they gd at losin it. No to mentoin id cards can b used 2 frame ppl 4 crimes by polis 2 make there figuers look beta.
NO ID CARDS
Posted by: trench, possilpark on 8:42pm Tue 25 Nov 08
bear, ahm gonny vote fur you next time, you are full of good advice....just as good as these urra wans ,,,,,an ah'm no kiddin.
Add your comment
Please note: to publish your comment you must be registered on this site. If you are already registered, please enter your details below.
Email:
Password:
Travel Shop
Airport Parking
Travel Insurance
Car Hire
Copyright © 2009 Newsquest (Herald & Times) Limited. All Rights Reserved
Terms of Use